Liberal U.S. justices lean toward death row inmate in mental health dispute

  • In US
  • 2017-04-24 17:58:53Z
  • By By Lawrence Hurley

By Lawrence Hurley

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Liberal U.S. Supreme Court justices on Monday indicated support for a convicted murderer held on Alabama's death row who argued he had a right to an independent medical expert to assess his mental health and potentially help him avoid execution.

The legal fight involving Alabama inmate James McWilliams assumed greater importance in the past week after two death row inmates who Arkansas plans to execute, Don Davis and Bruce Ward, had their cases put on holding pending the Supreme Court's decision regarding McWilliams, due by the end of June.

Questions posed by the justices during a one-hour argument in the case indicated the four liberals could be joined by conservative Anthony Kennedy, the court's frequent swing vote, in backing McWilliams, sentenced to death for raping, murdering and robbing a convenience store clerk in Tuscaloosa in 1984.

The nine-member court's other conservatives, including Donald Trump's newly seated appointee Neil Gorsuch, appeared more likely to vote against McWilliams.

At issue in his appeal is whether an indigent defendant like McWilliams during a trial in which his mental health is a pivotal matter is entitled to an expert witness completely independent of the prosecution.

The Supreme Court ruled in a 1985 case called Ake v. Oklahoma that indigent defendants are entitled to expert assistance. But the ruling did not specifically say the expert had to be assigned to assist the defense as opposed to being a neutral expert helping both sides. The question before the justices is whether the 1985 decision "clearly established" McWilliams' right to an expert who would assist only the defense.

"That's the question. And here it seems to me that this defendant certainly did not get that help," liberal Justice Stephen Breyer said.


McWilliams' lawyers noted that during his trial the only expert analysis of his mental health came from a witness provided by the state.

While some of the conservatives indicated that was enough, liberal Justice Elena Kagan said the 1985 ruling went further, noting that it was specific about the expert assisting the defense.

"It just seems that the premise of the entire opinion is you're on the defense team," Kagan said.

Kennedy indicated he thinks the 1985 ruling was ambiguous but that a ruling favoring McWilliams could be viewed as "simply a refinement of a clearly established right" outlined in the earlier case.

In the 1984 crime, McWilliams entered a convenience store, locked the doors, took money from clerk Patricia Reynolds, forced her into a back room, raped her, shot her 16 times with a pistol and left her to bleed to death. McWilliams, later caught driving a stolen car in possession of the murder weapon, was found guilty and sentenced to death in 1986.

The ruling in McWilliams' case could affect non-capital cases as well as death penalty cases.

Arkansas had planned to carry out eight executions in a span of 11 days. So far only one, Ledell Lee, has been executed. Two more executions were scheduled for later on Monday. The state's original plan called for the most executions by any state in the shortest period of time since the U.S. death penalty was reinstated in 1976.

The Supreme Court has shown little appetite for reconsidering whether the death penalty itself violates the U.S. Constitution's ban on cruel and unusual punishment, but has faulted the way some states handle capital punishment.

The court has rebuked Texas, the U.S. leader in executions, twice since February in cases involving racist testimony from an expert witness and the state's standard for assessing intellectual disabilities that could preclude execution.

(Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham)


More Related News

Brazil justice sends Temer graft probe to top prosecutor
Brazil justice sends Temer graft probe to top prosecutor
  • World
  • 2017-06-22 23:09:40Z

A justice at Brazil's Federal Supreme Court has delivered to the country's top prosecutor the bulk of an investigation into allegations that President Michel Temer took bribes in exchange for political favors doled out to meatpacker JBS SA. The office of Justice Edson Fachin said it sent a copy

Court lifts injunction on Mississippi law seen as anti-LGBT
Court lifts injunction on Mississippi law seen as anti-LGBT
  • US
  • 2017-06-22 20:09:13Z

Opponents said they would likely seek to overturn the decision, arguing that the measure allowed for sweeping discrimination against the LGBT community. A three-judge panel at the New Orleans-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed a lower court ruling that blocked the 2016 law, known as House Bill 1523 and backed by Christian groups, from taking effect. The panel said the plaintiffs, who included ordained ministers who have married same-sex couples and same-sex couples seeking to marry, did not have standing to bring the lawsuit.

Trump lawyers make final Supreme Court pitch on travel ban
Trump lawyers make final Supreme Court pitch on travel ban
  • US
  • 2017-06-21 16:49:25Z

By Lawrence Hurley WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The Trump administration on Wednesday made its final plea to the U.S. Supreme Court to allow its proposed ban on travelers from six Muslim-majority countries to go into effect as the justices weigh how to handle the hotly contested dispute. The court papers filed by President Donald Trump's administration complete the briefing on the government's emergency application asking the justices to block lower court injunctions in favor of challengers to the ban. In the court papers, Acting Solicitor General Jeff Wall said the lower courts had wrongly second-guessed the president on national security policy when reviewing the March 6 executive order.

Supreme Court ruling threatens massive talc litigation against J&J
Supreme Court ruling threatens massive talc litigation against J&J
  • US
  • 2017-06-20 23:40:23Z

New Jersey-based J&J has been battling a series of lawsuits over its talc-based products, including Johnson's Baby Powder, brought by around 5,950 women and their families. The company denies any link between talc and cancer. A fifth of the plaintiffs have cases pending in state court in St. Louis

Venezuela poised for new violence after security forces fatally shoot protester, 17
Venezuela poised for new violence after security forces fatally shoot protester, 17

A member of the riot security forces points what appears to be a pistol towards a crowd of demonstrators during a rally. Venezuelans are bracing for a further escalation of violence after a 17-year-old protester was shot dead by the national guard, and the supreme court announced charges against the country's attorney general - one of the most senior officials to speak out against the government of Nicolás Maduro.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: US

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.