Biden blasted for reviving Trump's Remain in Mexico policy

  • In Business
  • 2021-12-03 03:19:26Z
  • By BBC
Migrants on the Mexican side of the border
Migrants on the Mexican side of the border  

US President Joe Biden has come under fire for restoring a Trump-era policy that requires asylum seekers to wait in Mexico while their claims are processed.

Migrant groups said reinstating the Remain in Mexico programme would spur crime and violence in border camps.

Mr Biden had suspended the policy, calling it "inhumane", but was ordered by courts to resume it.

The US and Mexican governments confirmed they would revive it.

Mr Biden's administration has kept up one other major Trump-era border policy: Title 42, which allows for the quick expulsion of migrants on public health grounds.

Why is Remain in Mexico back?

Former US President Donald Trump introduced the programme, then known as the Migrant Protection Protocols, to send more than 60,000 asylum applicants back to Mexico.

Migrants were often left waiting in Mexico for months, where they sometimes fell prey to criminal gangs.

According to charity Human Rights First, there have been more than 1,500 publicly reported cases of kidnapping, rape, torture and other abuses against migrants returned to Mexico.

Mr Biden suspended the programme almost immediately after taking office, as part of a campaign pledge to reverse hardline immigration policies enacted by his predecessor.

  • What are Biden's challenges at the border?

In June, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas terminated the policy.

But in August a federal court Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk, a Trump appointee, ruled that the policy had been improperly cancelled.

The Biden administration is appealing against the decision.

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said on Thursday that the president stands by past remarks about the "unjustified human costs" of the programme.

"But we also believe in following the law," she said.

The policy has been revamped to address Mexico's concerns, including to limit time spent for each asylum application to six months.

Implementation is expected to begin next week at ports of entry in Texas and California.

What does Mexico have to gain?

Analysis box by Will Grant, Mexico and Central America correspondent
Analysis box by Will Grant, Mexico and Central America correspondent  

Immigration has again proven to be the main prism through which Washington views its relationship with Mexico.

It seems the numbers of people arriving at the US southern border - and the effect that is having on President Biden's standing in the polls - has meant the administration is happy enough to reinstate the law - albeit having been ordered to do so by the courts. Domestic US politics, as so often the case, plays a central role in its relationship with Mexico and Central America.

Yet one might well as ask what Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador has to gain by agreeing to carry out his side of the policy, namely accepting thousands of asylum-seekers into Mexican border towns to await their day in a US court. On the surface, he has added a more humanitarian veneer to the policy, tying down a timeline of 180 days in which asylum cases should be heard and development funds for Central America under the name "Planting Opportunities". But in reality, this is a political risk he can afford to take.

With asylum seekers likely to be living again in precarious conditions in dangerous border towns, the Mexican president may be considering that migrants will have less incentive to travel north. And in the meantime, he has undoubtedly created some useful leverage with President Biden in other areas. Rarely are such agreements reached without some form of quid pro quo across the border.

'A dark day'

The move was slammed by pro-immigration groups and lawmakers from Mr Biden's own Democratic party.

The American Immigration Council rejected the Biden team's "claims that it can administer the Remain in Mexico program in a more humane manner", adding: "Today is a dark day for the United States and for the rule of law."

By expanding the programme to include any migrants from the Western Hemisphere - including non-Spanish speaking groups such as Haitians - Mr Biden had "made the programme even broader than under Trump", the group said.

The UNHCR, the United Nations refugee agency, also condemned the move and refused to help implement the policy.

US-Mexico border crossing graphic
US-Mexico border crossing graphic  

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) said the resumption will lead to "horrific abuse, including torture, rape, and death".

Texas Democratic Congresswoman Veronica Escobar told The Hill newspaper that the policy "erodes our values as a country" and is "a violation of asylum processing".

She called for the White House to aggressively fight the order in court, and criticised Mr Biden for not having fixed the system after nearly a year in office.

Democratic Senator Bob Menendez urged Mr Biden to "make every effort" to overturn "this xenophobic and anti-immigrant policy for good".

Republican House Leader Kevin McCarthy welcomed the reinstatement of Return in Mexico.

"It is unfortunate that it took litigation to force the Biden administration's hand to apply this commonsense measure," he said.

You may also be interested in:


More Related News

Why Americans should care about Russian aggression against Ukraine
Why Americans should care about Russian aggression against Ukraine
  • World
  • 2022-01-21 12:00:20Z

President Biden needs to go to United Nations to rally the will to stop Putin, says retired Gen. Wesley Clark, former NATO Supreme Allied Commander

Letters: Nothing
Letters: Nothing 'ludicrous' in saying Black men are police enemy. Gun regulations would have saved man
  • US
  • 2022-01-21 11:09:04Z

Letters to the Editor

Biden Just Won
Biden Just Won't Admit When He's Screwed Up

Nicholas Kamm/AFP via Getty Don't count on a comeback for President Joe Biden. As conventional wisdom catches up with my rather negative critique of Biden's ...

Ukraine, midterms and Build Back Better: White House plays cleanup after Biden
Ukraine, midterms and Build Back Better: White House plays cleanup after Biden's marathon press conference

Biden took questions for nearly two hours Wednesday. Remarks about Ukraine and election integrity prompted the White House to clarify his comments.

The Left Already Hates the New Plan to Save Biden
The Left Already Hates the New Plan to Save Biden's Agenda

Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast/GettyAll throughout President Joe Biden's first year in office, progressives clung to the hope that ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Business