Jeremy Pruitt deceived us: Tennessee responds to NCAA notice of allegations


The University of Tennessee disputed the NCAA's finding that it failed to monitor the football program while recruiting violations were committed under fired coach Jeremy Pruitt.

Instead, the university said Pruitt, his wife and his staff knowingly concealed their malfeasance despite Tennessee's best efforts to follow NCAA rules in monitoring the football program. That was the university's only major dispute in responding to the NCAA notice of allegations.

The Knoxville News Sentinel, which is part of the USA TODAY Network, obtained the university's 108-page response to the NCAA on Thursday morning.

In the document, Tennessee had minor disputes with five of the 18 Level 1 violations that the NCAA found during its investigation. Otherwise, it agreed generally that rules were broken and that almost $60,000 of cash or gifts were provided to players and their families by Pruitt, his wife and numerous coaches, recruiting staff and at least one booster.

But the university argued that it was not guilty of the 18th violation - the most serious against the institution, failure to monitor the football program.

"Despite the University's monitoring efforts, athletics administrators and athletics compliance staffmembers were repeatedly deceived by the football program," Tennessee said in the response to the NCAA. "The University respectfully submits that it is unrealistic to expect an institution to prevent, or immediately detect, the intentional and concealed misconduct that occurred in this case."

The NCAA alleged the Level 1 violations - the most serious in its four-tier system - were committed by Jeremy and wife Casey Pruitt; assistant coaches Derrick Ansley, Shelton Felton and Brian Niedermeyer; recruiting staff members Drew Hughes, Bethany Gunn and Chantryce Boone; and an unnamed booster from 2018-21.

Tennessee argued those individuals knew what they were doing was wrong and intentionally kept the university in the dark.

"The factual information in this case demonstrates that experienced football coaches and non-coaching staff members knowingly violated longstanding and universally understood NCAA rules and went to considerable lengths to conceal their misconduct," the university said in its response. "The record also supports that the University monitored football recruiting visits in accordance with industry standards.

"As part of the University's monitoring efforts, athletics administration and athletics compliance staff maintained a physical presence in and around the football program (including embedding an experienced compliance staff member in the program)."

In its response, Tennessee cites far-from-drastic penalties handed down by the Committee on Infractions to LSU in September. The NCAA accepted LSU's self-imposed penalties including a $5,000 fine, a limit on official recruiting visits, a one-week ban on unofficial visits and recruiting communications in the football program and loss of seven recruiting evaluation days. The NCAA also ordered one year probation on the school and ordered a three-year show-cause on a former LSU assistant coach, neither of which were self-imposed by the school.

LSU was cited for ignoring a recruiting dead period instated during the COVID-19 pandemic. Tennessee argues that since the committee on infractions did not significantly increase penalties due to aggravating factors in that case, citing LSU's cooperation, it should treat UT similarly.

"Despite the University's best efforts, multiple members of the football staff, including (Jeremy) Pruitt, disregarded" the compliance office's efforts to keep recruiting within NCAA guidelines, the school said in its response.

In July, the NCAA delivered the notice of 18 Level 1 violations. Tennessee and the people named in the report had until late October to respond to the allegations, but the NCAA granted a 30-day extension to that deadline.

The NCAA enforcement staff now has 60 days to reply to these responses. So the next phase of the case could come as late as January.

The ongoing NCAA case from the Pruitt era is quite a contrast to the school's current football team under Josh Heupel, which is amid one of its best seasons since a 1998 national title run. The Vols have a 9-2 record and ranked No. 10 in the College Football Playoff rankings.

If Tennessee beats Vanderbilt on Saturday, it will post a 10-win season for the first time since 2007 and remain in contention for a New Year's Six bowl.

What has happened since NCAA investigation

UT football has transformed dramatically in the 18 months since Tennessee Chancellor Donde Plowman announced an internal investigation, fired Pruitt for cause, cleaned house in the football program and accepted athletics director Phillip Fulmer's retirement.

Plowman hired athletics director Danny White, who tabbed Heupel as football coach. In 2021, Heupel won the Steve Spurrier Award as the top first-year coach in college football with a roster that underwent self-imposed scholarship cuts.

This year's Tennessee team has exceeded expectations. Quarterback Hendon Hooker is a Heisman Trophy candidate. Wide receiver Jalin Hyatt is a frontrunner for the Biletnikoff Award. Heupel is an SEC coach of the year candidate. And the Vols have the No. 1-ranked offense in college football, built largely on players left from Pruitt's era.

But the NCAA case still lingers. And now comes the next step. Tennessee has been active in building its case.

The university paid $143,722 in legal fees to the firm Bond, Schoeneck & King from June to August, according to university records provided to Knox News. That represented its largest quarterly legal expense in a year. Invoices for September and October are not yet available.

Lawyers for Tennessee traveled to Indianapolis, the site of NCAA headquarters, on July 12 and Aug. 9.

From the beginning, the university took steps to assist the NCAA and perhaps mitigate penalties.

Tennessee self-reported infractions, conducted an internal investigation with high-powered lawyers, spent about $1.4 million in legal fees over the course of the entirety investigation, dug up new violations that NCAA investigators had not discovered and fired Pruitt for cause, along with additional coaches and recruiting staff members alleged to have committed violations.

"These actions by (UT) led to the fully-formed record that would not be possible without the significant actions taken by the institution," the NCAA said in its notice of allegations to UT.

Reach Adam Sparks at and on Twitter @AdamSparks.

This article originally appeared on Knoxville News Sentinel: Tennessee says Jeremy Pruitt deceived university in response to NCAA


More Related News

Texas basketball stays put at No. 10 in the AP Top 25 Poll
Texas basketball stays put at No. 10 in the AP Top 25 Poll

Texas holds steady at No. 10 following a 1-1 week.

LSU announces new
LSU announces new 'Bayou Traditions' NIL collective

LSU announced a step forward in the name, image and likeness game on Monday.

Jayden Daniels named top 101 player from 2022 season
Jayden Daniels named top 101 player from 2022 season

Daniels was one of the best players in college football this season.

LSU makes 4-star edge rusher
LSU makes 4-star edge rusher's top 6

The Tigers are a finalist for one of the top prospects in Louisiana in Kolaj Cobbins.

Suspect in LSU student Madison Brooks
Suspect in LSU student Madison Brooks' alleged rape charged in alleged 2020 sex assault
  • US
  • 2023-01-28 18:53:21Z

Kaivon Washington, 18, was charged with first-degree rape in an alleged 2020 assault. Washington is charged with third-degree rape in the recent Madison...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Football