Respect for Marriage Act: Why interracial marriage is also in the bill




  • In Business
  • 2022-12-08 18:18:57Z
  • By BBC
A black and white hand with a wedding ring
A black and white hand with a wedding ring  

The US House of Representatives has passed a landmark same-sex marriage protection bill that is being billed as a major breakthrough for LGBT couples.

The Respect for Marriage Act already passed the Senate with a 61-36 vote last week. It now heads to US President Joe Biden to be signed into law.

The act requires the federal government to recognise the validity of all marriages - including LGBT and same-sex matrimonies - conducted in states where they are legal.

"Today, we stand up to the values the vast majority of Americans hold dear - a belief in the dignity, beauty and divinity in every person in abiding respect for love so powerful that it binds two people together," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said on Thursday.

The bill also marks an important turning point in the decades-long process to protect interracial marriage.

It's been 55 years since a US Supreme Court ruling first made interracial marriage legal in every state, but it was not protected by federal law until now. Recent remarks by a justice of the top court has caused some concerns that gay marriage and interracial marriage could be overturned by a possible future court ruling.

The newest push to codify the right to gay and interracial marriage into law came after the conservative-dominated Supreme Court in June overturned the constitutional right to abortion, which had been legal nationwide for four decades.

Justice Clarence Thomas, writing his opinion in the abortion case, Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organization, called into question the legality of other rights that were established by Supreme Court verdicts, and not by congressional legislation.

He wrote that the court has a "duty" to "correct the error" of previous Supreme Court judgements that established the national right to contraception in 1965, overturned state anti-sodomy laws in 2003 and added the right to same-sex marriage in 2015.

Mr Thomas's opinion made no mention of the case that legalised interracial marriage in 1967 - Loving v Virginia.

Richard and Mildred Loving
Richard and Mildred Loving  

Court-watchers noted how that landmark case - like the three he mentioned - came down to the subject of due process and equal protections under the law.

Loving v Virginia was brought by a husband and wife who argued that the state of Virginia had unfairly discriminated against them by refusing to issue a marriage licence. At the time, 16 states still had laws against interracial marriage, known as anti-miscegenation laws.

Liberals said Mr Thomas' omission of the case was hypocritical and motivated by self-interest, given the fact that he has been in an interracial marriage since the 1980s. Conservatives said the black Supreme Court justice's marriage to a white woman is proof that there is no actual judicial threat to racially diverse marriages.

Cathryn Oakley, of the LGBT advocacy group Human Rights Campaign, says that there are currently no states challenging either interracial marriage or same-sex marriage, which are now both the "status quo" under US law.

What the Dobbs decision on abortion made clear to people, she says, is that "these things that we thought were settled law - which people have depended on, people have built their lives around - are in fact not as settled in the eyes of the US Supreme Court as they are in the eyes of the rest of America".

  • The 'accidental activist' behind US marriage equality

At least 94% of Americans approve of interracial marriage, according to a 2021 Gallup poll. The approval figure was only 4% when Gallup first began conducting the survey in 1958.

Figures show that such unions are happening more frequently, too.

Clarence Thomas and his wife, Ginni
Clarence Thomas and his wife, Ginni  

In 2019, 11% of all married US adults had a partner who was a different race from them, according to the Pew Research Center.

However, among newlyweds that year, 19% were entering into interracial unions.

John McKeon, a Democratic state assemblyman in New Jersey, last month submitted legislation to specifically legalise interracial marriage in New Jersey - one of only a few states that never banned it in the first place.

There is nothing in the US Constitution explicitly guaranteeing reproductive freedom, equal marriage or contraception, he says.

He argues that all those could be ended someday by a court of jurists who believe rights established by courts - and not legislatures - are not actually rights at all.

Mr McKeon was inspired to propose the legislation after his staff began investigating New Jersey law following the Dobbs decision, and were surprised to find no laws guaranteeing the right to interracial marriage.

New Jersey, he says, was among Democratic-leaning states that "rushed to make certain once Dobbs passed that reproductive freedom was part of our law".

"And similarly that that was done for access to contraception," he tells BBC News.

"And we had already done it as it related to marriage equality. But when I looked on the books, on interracial marriage there is nothing set forth in our law."

Although he recognises that a legal challenge is unlikely, it would be better, he says, "really to cross that T".

COMMENTS

More Related News

Nigeria
Nigeria's naira crisis: Supreme Court suspends banknote deadline
  • World
  • 2023-02-08 12:01:16Z

The deadline to stop using old naira notes was Friday but banks did not have enough new currency.

Biden Urges Congress to Codify Roe to Counteract States
Biden Urges Congress to Codify Roe to Counteract States' 'Extreme Abortion Bans'

President Biden during Tuesday night's State of the Union address urged Congress to codify Roe v. Wade to counteract Republican states' "extreme abortion...

Nigeria panel conducting army probe says it will refer rights violators for prosecution
Nigeria panel conducting army probe says it will refer rights violators for prosecution
  • US
  • 2023-02-07 14:18:46Z

A special Nigerian human rights panel began investigating on Tuesday Reuters reports that the army massacred children and ran a secret abortion programme...

Officer in charge of Brasilia security on Jan. 8 arrested
Officer in charge of Brasilia security on Jan. 8 arrested
  • US
  • 2023-02-07 10:44:15Z

BRASILIA/RIO DE JANEIRO (Reuters) -Brazil's federal police on Tuesday arrested the military police officer who led security operations in Brasilia on Jan. 8,...

Sarah Huckabee Sanders to deliver Republican response
Sarah Huckabee Sanders to deliver Republican response

Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who served in Trump's White House, will speak after Joe Biden.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • Beth Dutton Blue Coat
    (2022-12-09 05:41:18Z)

    This is such awesome content i got to read after lot of time. Its so interesting as well as informative. I am sure everyone who read it got a lot to learn from it.

    REPLY
  • togel online
    (2022-12-09 06:01:23Z)

    The mentioned site is like a great assistance for all the people trying to connect to someone like them, for further information take a look at their site! They are amazing!

    REPLY
  • Green Valley Lahore Payment Plan
    (2022-12-09 07:37:52Z)

    Nice post ! Green Valley Lahore Payment Plan is a destined to-be-LDA-endorsed delightful private society created by Pak Designers and situated at

    REPLY

Top News: Business