Supreme Court rules on part of NC's voter ID case: Here's what it does (and doesn't) do

  • In Business
  • 2022-06-23 14:15:26Z
  • By Raleigh News and Observer

The constitutionality of North Carolina's voter ID law is still up in the air - but on Thursday, Republican lawmakers won a related legal fight at the U.S. Supreme Court.

The justices didn't rule on the voter ID case itself. But they did rule that GOP leaders can intervene in the case as defendants.

That may sound like just a procedural update, but it's important for two reasons.

For one, it gives Republicans lawmakers permission to hire outside lawyers to defend the state, instead of continuing to use lawyers from the N.C. Department of Justice under Attorney General Josh Stein. That gives them more control over the arguments and legal strategy.

Even though Stein's office has been winning the case so far, Republicans have said his lawyers can't be trusted. Other Democratic politicians have said the voter ID law is racially discriminatory and should be overturned.

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers North Carolina, had denied lawmakers' request to intervene in the case. They noted that Stein's office won the argument in front of them when they heard it and said the GOP couldn't point to anything he had done wrong in winning the case for them. On Thursday, the Supreme Court overturned that Court of Appeals ruling.

The decision doesn't mean Stein's office is kicked off the case. He's still defending the N.C. State Board of Elections, who are the main defendants. But Republican legislators can now hire their own lawyers and craft their own legal strategy, in addition to the case made by Stein and the elections officials.

Republican lawmakers also had a second reason to want to intervene: They're now allowed to block any potential settlement agreement that might otherwise have ended the lawsuit.

When legislators passed the 2021 state budget, they attached several laws that were unrelated to state spending, including a new law giving themselves the power to block settlements in lawsuits they're involved in, even just as intervenors, which they now are.

Before the Supreme Court's ruling, the voter ID case could've been settled if a judge approved an agreement between the liberal challengers and the N.C. State Board of Elections, which has a Democratic majority. Now Senate leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore must also sign off on any proposed settlement.

What's next for voter ID lawsuits

With the legislature now officially part of the case, federal courts can turn their attention to the question of whether the state's voter ID law is constitutional.

A 2013 version of the law that Republicans passed over Democratic objections was struck down in federal court for intentionally targeting African-American voters "with almost surgical precision."

After that loss the legislature tried again, passing a similar law in 2018 that Republicans said had enough changes that it should no longer be considered racially discriminatory.

But in 2019 a trial court judge ruled that the law still appeared to be racially motivated. In 2020, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that decision, saying the law should be allowed to stand.

This is the case the U.S. Supreme Court is now considering. But however the justices rule, it is unlikely to be the final word on the state's voter ID law.

Two other lawsuits are moving forward in state courts. One argues that the law itself is unconstitutional. The other argues that the legislature didn't have the power to write the law in the first place, due to unconstitutional gerrymandering.


More Related News

Supreme Court: MD officials must enforce anti-picketing laws on abortion rights protests outside justices
Supreme Court: MD officials must enforce anti-picketing laws on abortion rights protests outside justices' homes

An armed man last month allegedly made threats against Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh near the justice's suburban Washington, D.C., home.

U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices
U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices' homes
  • US
  • 2022-07-02 19:07:42Z

The U.S. Supreme Court's top security officer has asked Maryland Governor Larry Hogan to enforce laws barring picketing outside the Maryland homes of high...

Australians rally against U.S. overturning of key abortion ruling
Australians rally against U.S. overturning of key abortion ruling
  • US
  • 2022-07-02 06:47:45Z

Thousands of Australians joined raucous protests across the country on Saturday against the U.S. Supreme Court's overturning of women's constitutional right ...

Abortion drug maker says Mississippi can
Abortion drug maker says Mississippi can't ban pill despite Supreme Court ruling
  • US
  • 2022-07-01 17:17:39Z

(Reuters) -The maker of a drug used in medication abortions has told a federal judge that the U.S. Supreme Court's recent ruling eliminating the nationwide...

Explainer-How the conservative Supreme Court is reshaping U.S. law
Explainer-How the conservative Supreme Court is reshaping U.S. law
  • US
  • 2022-07-01 16:52:33Z

The U.S. Supreme Court's most consequential term in decades, with blockbuster rulings on abortion, guns, religion and climate change policy, illustrated how ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • dark web links
    (2022-06-24 05:24:28Z)

    So, basically, your iPhone is a mini computer that can connect you to the internet.

    However, your iPhone cannot view the dark web or secure websites

  • deep web
    (2022-06-24 05:53:44Z)

    How do I get on the dark web with your iPhone? The first thing you must do is to search for an appropriate website that offers the dark web. A large number of these websites will be located at the bottom or side of any major search engine. You should be able to find several at once

  • dark web links
    (2022-06-24 06:11:29Z)

    Most of the websites that offer links that allow you to get on the dark web, use networks that are controlled by the government

  • dark web sites
    (2022-06-24 06:33:51Z)

    How do I get on the dark web with your iPhone and submit a link without revealing my location? In the past, many people have used free methods to try to expose their location.

  • dark web
    (2022-06-24 08:54:10Z)

    your fingertips. However, what many people don't realize is that the dark web is just as accessible from your iPhone just like the rest of the internet. How can this be? Well to answer this question we need to look at how you can access the dark web on your iPhone.

  • work from home jobs
    (2022-06-24 09:16:13Z)

    Also, try to participate in various events in your country. It is always good to promote a new business opportunity in your area so that you will be able to spread the word and gain lots of popularity.

  • affiliate marketing success
    (2022-06-24 10:12:11Z)

    As an affiliate marketer in India, you will be working for a big company but it doesn't mean that you won't have any contact with other affiliate marketers. You will surely gain a lot of information and experience when you work with other affiliate marketers from other countries.


Top News: Business