Supreme Court turns away school's appeal of sex-assault case


FALLS CHURCH, Va. (AP) - The U.S. Supreme Court won't hear an appeal from a Virginia school board that says it shouldn't be held liable for the alleged sexual assault of a student by a classmate on a band trip.

The court without comment on Monday rejected the appeal from the Fairfax County School Board. The case will now go to trial in federal court in Alexandria, Virginia.

The case turned on whether a school system can be held liable under Title IX for a single alleged assault when there had been no prior notice of a problem. Title IX is the federal law that prevents discrimination on the basis of sex.

The female student who says she was assaulted, identified only as Jane Doe, filed the lawsuit in 2018. She said a male classmate at Oakton High School sexually assaulted her on a school bus during an out-of-state band trip in 2017.

In 2019, after a two-week trial, a civil jury acquitted the school system of wrongdoing. It found that the girl had indeed been assaulted, but it said the school system had not received "actual notice" of the assault.

In 2021, though, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated the lawsuit in a 2-1 ruling. The majority opinion said it was clear that the school system had notice of the assault because the girl herself told administrators she'd been touched without her consent. A dissenting opinion, though, concluded that the trial verdict should stand because after-the-fact notice about an isolated, one-time incident afforded no real opportunity for the school district to take preventive action.

The full 4th Circuit then issued a 9-6 en banc opinion affirming that the suit should be reinstated. Judges in the majority said that if school systems can't be held liable for their response to a single incident, it would amount to giving them "one free rape."

Dissenting judges said the majority opinion vastly expands the liability school systems face under Title IX.

The school board then sought review from the Supreme Court, which was rejected on Monday. Some progressive groups had criticized the school board for pursuing a legal theory that they said would restrict the legal rights of sex-assault victims.

In a statement, one of Jane Doe's lawyers with the Public Justice, a nonprofit public-interest legal group, said the Supreme Court was correct to turn the school board's appeal aside.

"What a shame the School Board wasted taxpayer dollars asking the Supreme Court to adopt positions the Fourth Circuit and the Department of Justice have called 'absurd,'" Alexandra Brodsky said.

Fairfax County Public Schools said in a statement that the Supreme Court's refusal to take the case "leaves these important legal questions unsettled. Fairfax County Public Schools asked the high court to resolve these uncertainties because Congress never intended for schools to be privately sued for money damages when everyone agrees the harassment could not have been foreseen."

The Supreme Court on Monday also declined to hear an appeal filed by the University of Toledo in a similar case.


More Related News

Trans rapist Isla Bryson
Trans rapist Isla Bryson 'tried to join self-defence class for female sexual assault victims'
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 14:46:57Z

Transgender predator Isla Bryson tried to join a self-defence programme for female victims of sexual assault while awaiting trial for rape, it has emerged.

As youth violence grows, Erie School Board wants metal detectors in elementary schools
As youth violence grows, Erie School Board wants metal detectors in elementary schools
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 11:31:41Z

Erie School Board ready to vote on superintendent's proposal linked to concerns over Erie gang activity, shooting by 6-year-old in Newport News, Va.

Can the Diocese of Providence be sued over clergy sexual abuse? Appeal argues it was a perpetrator
Can the Diocese of Providence be sued over clergy sexual abuse? Appeal argues it was a perpetrator
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 11:24:51Z

A previous ruling found that the Diocese of Providence, by definition, were non-perpetrators in cases of clergy sexual abuse. An appeal is arguing that...

'Dances With Wolves' actor Nathan Chasing Horse told wives to 'shoot it out' if police came to house: report
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 10:41:19Z

The Associated Press released new details Wednesday in the arrest of "Dances With Wolves" actor Nathan Chasing Horse who is facing charges for multiple sex...

Israeli AG: Netanyahu cannot be involved in legal overhaul
Israeli AG: Netanyahu cannot be involved in legal overhaul
  • World
  • 2023-02-02 08:05:15Z

Israel's attorney general has told Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu he must avoid being involved in an overhaul to the country's judicial system proposed by...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • Orlando Termite Control
    (2022-12-04 13:45:12Z)

    It's superior, however , check out material at the street address.

  • Pest Control Oviedo
    (2022-12-04 13:49:09Z)

    I also wrote an article on a similar subject will find it at write what you think.

  • accbuzz 80
    (2022-12-14 15:31:54Z)

    Creating a blog is a great way to market your business. buy gmail pva accounts However, it is important to remember that it takes time and effort to get it up and running. One of the best ways to make your blog effective is to stick to it for at least one year. That way, your blog will be popular and grow your audience. You will have to invest time and resources into making your blog successful. But once you have achieved success, buy twitter pva accounts it will be worth it.

  • lake
    (2023-01-24 12:17:29Z)

    Mmm.. estimable to be here in your report or notify, whatever, I repute I should moreover process strong for my have website want I play some salubrious further updated busy in your location.