Tech industry files emergency application to block controversial Texas social media law




 

Trade industry groups representing tech giants, such as Google and Facebook, have filed an emergency application with the Supreme Court to block HB 20. That's the controversial law Texan law that bars social media websites from removing or restricting content based on "the viewpoint of the user or another person." It also allows users to sue large platforms with more than than 50 million active monthly users if they believe they were banned for their political views. As The Washington Post reports, it reflects Republicans' claims that they're being being censored by "Big Tech."

A federal judge blocked HB 20 from being implemented last year, but the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals overturned that decision recently. The panel of judges agreed with the state of Texas that social networks are "modern-day public squares," which means they're banned from censoring certain viewpoints. One of the judges also said that social networks aren't websites but "internet providers" instead. The panel allowed the law to take effect while its merits are still being litigated in lower court.

NetChoice and the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA), the groups representing the tech industry, have maintained that the law is an attack on the First Amendment and have previously questioned its constitutionality. In their emergency application, they said HB 20 is an "unprecedented assault on the editorial discretion of private websites... that would fundamentally transform their business models and services."

They explained that under the law, platforms would have no choice but to allow the dissemination of "all sorts of objectionable viewpoints," such as Russian propaganda justifying the invasion of Ukraine, posts supporting neo-Nazis, KKKs and Holocaust deniers, as well as posts encouraging dangerous behavior, such as disordered eating. "The Fifth Circuit has yet to offer any explanation why the District Court's thorough opinion was wrong," they wrote in their application (PDF).

NetChoice and CCIA also argue that by allowing the law to be enforced, it could influence and interfere with the decision of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. The Atlanta-based appeals court will decide the fate of a similar law in Florida that was initially blocked by a federal judge for violating Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.

COMMENTS

More Related News

Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court
Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court's Jackson

(Reuters) -President Joe Biden on Wednesday nominated three women to serve as appellate judges including Florence Pan, who would succeed U.S. Supreme Court...

Democratic candidates for Polk County attorney call for gun control after Texas shooting
Democratic candidates for Polk County attorney call for gun control after Texas shooting
  • US
  • 2022-05-25 04:31:09Z

Laura Roan, Kimberly Graham and Kevin McCarthy spoke in a debate Tuesday sponsored by the Des Moines Register and the Drake University Law School.

Woman found dead in Medford recycling bin applied for restraining order weeks before her death
Woman found dead in Medford recycling bin applied for restraining order weeks before her death
  • US
  • 2022-05-24 23:23:06Z

Boston 25 has been looking into city records, court records, and calls for police at the address where Barbara Novaes' body was found at 21 Emery Street in...

Courts thwart abortion bans in Iowa and other Republican-led states
Courts thwart abortion bans in Iowa and other Republican-led states

An Iowa Supreme Court decision is holding back the state's solidly Republican Legislature and governor from banning abortion if the U.S. Supreme Court...

Florida Republicans eye total ban on abortions
Florida Republicans eye total ban on abortions

The GOP lawmakers' comments indicate that the fight over abortion rights in Florida is just beginning.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Economy